I’ve written before about the doctor whose keen listening and holistic approach helped set me on a path to wellness, about his recommendations to me on exercise, healthier eating, massage, caffeine, and saying yes to myself. What I haven’t shared before were his parting words to me before sending me off to the health food store for some B vitamins:
“Oh, and Kristen, if there’s anybody in your life you need to forgive, you need to do that now.”
His words felt like a punch in the gut. Eliminating coffee? Fine. Trying out meditation? No problem. Cutting back on sugar? I’m your girl. But forgiving? Let alone forgetting? I’ll pass.
You see, I’m a champion grudge holder. I have a formidable memory and packed into the nooks and folds of my brain – right next to the 80s song lyrics and directly behind the German dative prepositions (aus, außer, bei, mit, nach, seit, von, zu) - is a list of every slight, every rude remark, every unreturned phone call.
I replay the movie in my mind of the time the sibling of one of my older brother’s soccer teammates teased my little brother – who has spina bifida – for being slow in the game of tag we were playing on the sideline. I remember standing in a New Haven backyard at a college house party when a friend of my roommate’s said, the third time we were introduced, “Oh, no, we’ve never met.” I still stare daggers at a colleague of my husband’s who never emailed me back when I wrote him asking for help when I first started freelancing.
It’s a terrible quality. It’s ugly. It’s petty. It’s an awful thing to model for my kids. And I never really realized how much my habit weighed me down until I so forcefully resisted trying to change it when my doctor pointed it out.
Then last week happened. I had two non-negotiable writing deadlines. Meanwhile, my three year old had a fever that kept him home from preschool. My daughter’s cold spiraled into a double ear infection that had me keeping an hourly vigil by her crib two nights in a row. My husband – who is never sick – had a cold that he couldn’t shake, and one that kept him – and me – up two other nights with his coughing and sneezing.
I had to take care of my family. I had to get my assignments done. So I turned to some old friends for support in my time of need: Coke Zero and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. On Thursday, exhausted from sleep debt, I mainlined the Coke all afternoon so I could work while my kids napped – fitfully – in the next room. After I got them to sleep at night, I cozied up with a bag of mini-Reese’s while I copy-edited my piece.
The next morning, confronting the pile of red foil wrappers in the garbage can and the empty two-liter bottle in the recycling bin next to it, I did something that surprised me. I closed the lid and said, “Oh, well.”
I didn’t curse myself for breaking my caffeine rule. I didn’t beat myself up for eating more sugar in an hour than I had in the previous month.
I let it go.
In the past, slipping up has always led me to return to the behavior I was trying to change. Nibble one fingernail? Forget this whole giving-up-nail-biting plan. Miss one run? Maybe running isn’t for me after all. But this time, after I took out the trash, I didn’t go back to the caffeine. I didn’t help myself to rest of the chocolate in the pantry. I thought about why I had made the changes I’d made, considered how far I’d come, and went back to my new way of doing things.
I messed up. I forgave myself. And I realized that forgiving myself for breaking my own rules helped me keep following them.
It makes me wonder if forgiving others might feel really good too.
Are you good about practicing forgiveness? Any tips for this veteran grudge keeper?
Image: Untitled by wrestlingentropy via Flickr under a Creative Commons license.
{ 33 comments… read them below or add one }
Bravo! Though somewhat different, I’ve found in the last few years I’m more able not to let a single slip up spiral into a full-fledged spiral of self-loathing and bad behavior. It took me a while to observe it – but isn’t it wonderful? Maybe this is maturity, finally, creeping in for us? :) xox
If older means wiser, I’m all for it! :)
I thought that I was not a grudge holder, but, now that you mention it, I do remember, in detail, the events that left me hurt (and some of them happened in middle school). Perhaps there are a few things I’m holding on to.
Oh, and the whole fingernail thing? I totally relate.
Once again, my dear, you and I are very much alike. xo
Oh, this is a wonderful post. Being able to let oneself off the hook is an amazing gift.
This may sound corny, but — one of my best practices for forgiveness is something I keep printed out on my bedside table, so I see it every night when I take off my glasses before bed. It’s a rendering in English of the traditional (Jewish) prayer for forgiveness said before going to sleep. And I love it. You can find it, if you’re so inclined, here at this post: http://velveteenrabbi.blogs.com/blog/2011/09/the-vidui-prayer-of-yom-kippurand-of-every-night.html
I don’t manage to say it every night. But I say it more often than not. And I think it really makes a difference.
Wow, Rachel, thank you so much for bringing that prayer to my attention. I love its sense of release and its acknowledgment that we all have sins that we’d like to see “blotted out.” I have also found that the very act of meditating on an idea – whether through formal prayer, mantra repetition, or just deep breathing – helps me be more peaceful about it. For some reason, I hadn’t thought about meditating on forgiveness, but now feels like a good time to start.
Brava! I love reading about all these changes you’re making – I never thought I could until I did, and ever since, I’ve been an advocate for change, especially when a behavior is impeding our own growth or is detrimental to our relationships.
However, this forgiveness you speak of is a tough one for me too, but I also realize that with the only way I could make any progress in parenting is to forgive myself my own shortcomings on days that I’ve not been able to meet my own expectations and try to be better the next day. Every day we try right?
I’d say forgiving yourself is certainly a piece of the practice of grudge-yielding! Even if the things we forgive ourselves for aren’t necessarily on the same scale as the slights or hurts we’ve received from others.
I hadn’t thought much about what a grudge really is until I read this post, and I think there’s a distinction between anger we hold on to for single offenses (large or small) and anger we can’t shake for long-term, repeatedly inflicted wounds. I tend to struggle with forgiving in the latter case. For the former, I usually have to assess whether it’s worth clearing the air with dialogue (sometimes people are oblivious and offend without realizing it) or just letting the situation go because it won’t have a lasting impact on what happens going forward (whatever it was, it was just unfortunate, but the likelihood that it will happen again or that I will have to interact with the person is too low to make it worth expending the energy of more anger once the initial emotion flames itself out).
So, my tip from my own grudge-keeping experience? Tackle the grudges that take up more emotional real estate than they deserve. Save that rage up for the really big stuff — er, I mean, working to improve the really big stuff ;)
CT:
Solution=voodoo dolls. I love you.
I think that makes a lot of sense, CT. Reading your comment, I wonder if my strong aversion to conflict is closely tied to my grudge-keeping. It seems so grown-up and reasonable to clear the air by talking it out, but – sadly – my MO seems to be putting on a happy face while stewing on the inside. Definitely something to work on.
This is the best kind of letting go, and for some of us (myself included), the most difficult. We hold ourselves to higher standards than anyone else – or than anyone else ever would.
This is happy news. (And hoping you’re back to taking excellent care of yourself.)
Dear Veteran Grudge-Keeper,
Meet your sister.
xoxo
I’ve always wanted a sister and I think you would make a rather fine one. xo
I think my combination of a very good memory and a sensitive soul made me a professional grudge keeper. In recent years, it’s gotten better. It’s not that I don’t get hurt, but I am better at letting it go. I guess there’s less room in my mind for useless grudges. Kudos for enjoying your Coke Zero and your Reese’s and not beating yourself up about it.
Oh Kristen, I literally just wrote a post about this as well…it was very personal and I’m debating whether I should publish it or not. We are always thinking along such parallels!
I can definitely relate. When I was younger I had even let go of some precious friendships because there were certain transgressions I just couldn’t get past. To be honest, I almost did the same thing a year ago. In every case I am grateful that my friends were much more generous than I; because of them we are still friends today.
I am learning to let go of the “small” things. I’m learning to look at the big picture, which is to see our friendship as being bigger than any slight or offense. If my friend overall cares for me and is a good person, then I need to see everything in that context. Any irritation or perceived offense can be discussed and resolved. Anyway, that is what I am learning but only very recently.
And you brought up an excellent point – that maybe if we can learn to forgive ourselves first, then we can learn to forgive others. Maybe it is all about holding up standards that are not realistic, and we all deserve to be human and forgiven.
Wonderful post and lots to think about. Thanks for writing about this and for being so honest!
Oh, Cecilia, I really do hope you’ll publish your piece. You and I are so often on the same wavelength and I know I’d love to hear even more about your experiences and thoughts on this topic.
What a great topic to write about! Thanks for sharing your personal struggling with forgiving. Honestly, I think it’s a lot easier to forgive ourselves than someone else. As for the Diet Coke and chocolate candy, you’re right to give yourself a break. Sometimes, you’ve got to do what you’ve got to do.
I personally think there’s a big difference between holding a grudge and forgiving someone. Holding a grudge may not be rational and can eat you up. Not forgiving is intentional and doesn’t mean you think about it every day. It’s more the fact that you make it clear to the other person they did something unacceptable that crossed sacred boundaries. I’ll forgive people who hurt me by accident. I won’t forgive people who purposely hurt me and don’t acknowledge or apologize. I think you have to earn forgiveness to deserve it. There is a very short list of people in my life I can’t forgive for what they did. I don’t really feel contempt for them, rather indifference, as in they don’t deserve my attention. I don’t know if that’s right, but it works for me.
I think you make a really important distinction here. There are definitely transgressions that don’t deserve forgiveness and each individual has the right to decide for herself whether or not to extend forgiveness. (To be honest, I think that’s what initially irked me about my doctor’s recommendation. And I’m still not convinced that forgiveness is a goal I’m working toward in every situation.) What I do need to work on is not carrying those mindless grudges. You’re right: they can eat you up if you give them that power.
I was thinking more about this last night and really, not everyone should be forgiven. Yes, if they make a mistake and apologize for it, no need to hold grudges. But if they purposely hurt you and don’t feel remorse for it, would should you forgive them? It doesn’t mean it has to eat you up but I don’t believe you should forgive someone just for the sake of it. What will they do then? Continue their behavior with other people because they’ve been forgiven before? I believe in karma and forgiveness can get in the way. So let karma works its ways.
Also, think about our judicial system. When criminals get caught and serve time, they don’t get forgiven when they get out. Instead they carry a criminal record for the rest of their life to remind them that what they did should not be forgotten or forgiven.
Agreed. I’m definitely not in favor of forgiveness that’s akin to enabling. (There’s a parenting lesson in there, too: if we let our kids get away with the same thing over and over, why would they ever behave any differently?)
Wow Kristen, this is so powerful. Oy, I hold onto grudges too. When I was in my yoga teacher training we focused a LOT on forgiveness (it totally sucked and was the hardest part). Rolf said, “You haven’t forgiven anything until you have forgiven the unforgivable” and it really felt like a punch in the gut. Forgiveness requires SO much patience.
I love how you forgave yourself – very inspirational. Thank you! I am of the mindset of ‘oh, fine I’ll just finish the bag,” … just to beat myself up. Awesome post and beautiful writing per usual.
No tips, but just some commiseration. I’m also a horrible grudge holder. It’s something I have to work on every. single.day. But I hope that I’m getting better.
I’m always glad to know that I’m not alone in my idiosyncrasies. So the commiseration helps, Meryl. A lot. Feeling like less of an oddball always does. :)
It sounds like there are quite a few of us here. Do me wrong and you obtain a special place in the corner of my shriveled black heart where I keep your picture as a reminder of your transgressions.
It has taken many years to adjust my attitude and to let go of some of that. It has felt pretty good to let go, but it hasn’t been easy. Nor have I let go of everything because some don’t deserve the second chance.
Fantastic post! This really spoke to me: “I messed up. I forgave myself. And I realized that forgiving myself for breaking my own rules helped me keep following them.” I’m slowly getting there myself, but hadn’t verbalised it yet.
Self forgiveness – the hardest one for me. I relate to every brilliant word and the fingernails, definitely the fingernails. Lovely post – one with a message I hope to internalize and remember.
I’m still struggling with that all or nothing behavior. It’s inspiring that you were able to move on so quickly!
When am I going to grow up?! argh :-)
I am not proud of it, but I am an extraordinarly gifted grudge holder. I can even be thoroughly disgusted with you still, yet remain so neutral you’d think I was OK with whatever you did to piss me off. I replay scenarios where I respond differently, there are different outcomes to whatever happened between us and I always win. Always.
As for the forgiveness of self, I’m not there yet either. Whenever I do something that I told myself I was no longer going to do I beat myself up as badly as I do the people in my imaginary “get-back” scenarios.
Ooh, yes, a woman after my own heart! I also have the neutral front mastered. I was actually just talking with a friend about whether it would be better – emotionally speaking – to let my real feelings show on my face. I’m not so sure.
This is a marvelous post! We all need to forgive ourselves more often…especially working moms! And the real reason behind forgiving others is so we can move past and onto better health; emotionally, physically and spiritually. But it’s soooo hard sometimes.
I read this post and wanted – no needed- to respond, but I was interrupted by life. Oh Kristen, this is so very powerful. If we forgive a little thing to ourselves and feel better, what happens when we release the big ones?
I know in my head only that anger only hurts myself, but my heart is scared of letting go of the hurts. It feels like an invitation to reopen the wounds of the past. But perhaps it’s the only way to let those scars truly heal.
Gorgeous and so very thought provoking.
I don’t know if it’s that I can’t forgive myself. For me it might be more that I’m very, very hard on myself. My expectations are very high. And I’ve passed that onto one of my kids, so it’s really important that I model handling my mistakes better so that she can handle hers better, you know?
Yup, I know *exactly* what you mean.