
Tuesday night is date night chez Motherese. Last Tuesday, just after I had changed out of my maple syrup and strawberry encrusted t-shirt and shorts, Beloved Babysitter had arrived, and I was headed out the door to meet Husband and some friends for drinks, Big Boy burst out in floods of tears.
Assuming he was sad at the idea of my leaving, I (arrogantly, apparently, and misguidedly) tried to comfort him: “Beloved Babysitter is going to give you and Tiny Baby dinner tonight. Daddy and I will be back soon, Big Boy. I love you.”
Turns out Big Boy wasn’t sad to see me go; he was sad about something much more profound.
“Tiny Baby is going to die someday.”
Woo, boy.
It all began, I suppose, with Big Boy’s fascination with dinosaurs. What started out with one silly board book quickly blossomed into an all-out obsession. He asked questions; we answered to the best of our knowledge. (And please note that my own knowledge was thrown for a loop when it was revealed to me that brontosaurus is no longer considered a dinosaur. Say what!?)
And talk turned, eventually, to why the dinosaurs aren’t around anymore (Jurassic Park notwithstanding).
“Well, they’re extinct.”
“What’s ‘ecktinct?’”
“Well, scientists think that an asteroid hit the Earth and that the temperature changed and that all the dinosaurs died out. They became extinct.”
“What’s ‘died?’”
So there it is. The first of the Big Questions.
And one that led us into a discussion of the fact that all living things are born and then, eventually, die. Some things live only a day, if they’re lucky. Like the mayflies that I remember lining the deck of the steamboat that hosted some of our annual childhood summer vacations. Some live decades longer than humans. Like the Galapagos tortoise from one of Big Boy’s storybooks.
And some can expect to live to 78.2. Like us.
And maybe we shouldn’t have gone there. Maybe we should have stuck with the “all dinosaurs evolved into birds” theory and saved a discussion of birth and life and death for another day.
But we didn’t.
And now this: “Tiny Baby is going to die someday.”
So what did I do? How did I respond?
First, I hugged him. To comfort him, of course. To try to make him understand that no one in this house is dying on my watch. To comfort him, yes, but also to think.
But the funny part is that my mind went blank. I didn’t have THE answer, but I did have AN answer. And I gave it to him.
“That’s right. He will. Someday.” And that’s true. “But not for a very, very long time.” And I hope that’s true too.
And he looked up at me with his giant two-year old blue eyes, his tear-moistened eyelashes thick like flower petals, and he cried some more. Cried at the idea of his brother dying someday.
Then he stopped, his body still heaving occasionally as his breath regulated itself, and he looked at me.
“Like the dinosaurs, Mommy?”
“Yes, baby, like the dinosaurs.”
And he seemed to get it.
But should he be made to “get it,” I wonder, at age two? Should I have told my baby that his little brother is indeed going to die?
The trouble is, I’m not ready to answer these Big Questions for him when I’m not yet sure how to answer them for myself.
But what feels right is to be honest. To channel the book of Ecclesiastes via Pete Seeger and the Byrds:
To Everything (Turn, Turn, Turn)
There is a season (Turn, Turn, Turn)
And a time to every purpose, under Heaven
A time to be born, a time to die
A time to plant, a time to reap
A time to kill, a time to heal
A time to laugh, a time to weep…
A time to build up, a time to break down
A time to dance, a time to mourn
A time to cast away stones, a time to gather stones together…
A time of love, a time of hate
A time of war, a time of peace
A time you may embrace, a time to refrain from embracing…
A time to gain, a time to lose
A time to rend, a time to sew
A time for love, a time for hate
A time for peace, I swear it’s not too late
My friend Liz at …but then I had kids faced a similar conversation with her son, Ben, last week. Please check out her post to see how she and her husband handled Ben’s Big Question.
How do handle the Big Questions with your kids? How did your parents handle them with you? Is honesty always the best policy?